Apollo Subscribe Collector Services
Comment

Drawing in museums is a form of respect – let’s not ruin it

30 April 2016

At lunchtimes, I go to the British Museum to draw. It’s never not full of school children, performing their dutiful rites in the Egyptian rooms – cataloguing mummification urns and cat gods – or sitting on the floor in the Anglo-Saxon galleries, listening to stories of Sutton Hoo. There are tourists too, thousands of them, there for the Rosetta Stone and the Elgin Marbles. My favourite subjects, the Cycladic sculptures, are dotted along a corridor between the entrance shop and the café. I don’t mind: no one expects to find the British Museum empty any more; it’s an effective modern machine, not a sleepy repository of treasures. But I do think I’ve as much a right to be there as anyone else: it’s not I who get in their way, it’s they who get in mine; standing in front of Lely’s Venus to take pictures while I pause, mid stroke, and try to hold the image in mind until they move on. Some days you can’t catch more than a few seconds’ continual study, so I go to the quieter rooms – Ancient Crete, say – and look at things there.

It’s not only art students who sketch in museums and galleries, though I did lots of it when I was one. Drawing is a form of knowing; the best way, I think, of seeing. At the very least it shows how little you really see when you’re not drawing. The work isn’t in the hand so much as the mind – it’s not dexterity you gain especially, nor do you always get better at making things on paper look as they really are, but you start to alter the way you see them in the first place. You learn to flatten and expand space, to fix things in the mind’s eye; not just to arrest them, like a camera, but to hold the aspects in relation to one another as you move between and over them. The hand is just the extension of the mind, concentrated through the eye, hovering, taut and drawn out; and you try to keep it there, poised, as you work and rework what you see. You stop hearing the voices around you or noticing the people walking back and forth. Time passes in an instant.

It’s not essential to copy great works of art, but it is unlike other forms of drawing. You get to know the objects inside out and to see them as the artist did – fields of dimensions and decisions and measurements. It makes you a better art historian and a better artist, and it’s a form of respect, to know them so intimately. Most galleries are very good about sketching – I’ve seen artists with their oil paints out in front of Rubens’ Samson and Delilah – and it’s in their interest. Artists have always stolen from other artists.

But the gallery conditions that enable the unfolding of stools for hour-long residencies are no longer those of major London exhibitions, which have grown ever more popular, crowded and crushed. Most are timed, for a start – you must move briskly to prevent congestion – and now the V&A has forbidden sketching, along with photography, at its new exhibitions about Botticelli and the history of underwear, just as it did for its David Bowie one a few years ago. (What counts as sketching anyway? Are notebooks confiscated? Do doodles count?)

The idea is to keep people moving in synchronised channels – exhibition spaces as crowd control – and anyone who went to the Rembrandt show at the National Gallery last year knows how desperate it can be when that goes wrong: pictures obscured, crowds five people deep in places; the experience like wading through a crowd at Glastonbury, desperate just to make it to the other side. It’s annoying that we can’t sketch knickers at the V&A, but more annoying that footfall takes precedence over engagement. It would be useful if galleries, instead of banning drawing, thought about ways to make their popular exhibitions accessible to those who, for whatever reason, like to go slowly as they look.

There’s never been a better time to subscribe to Apollo magazine. Start your subscription today with 3 issues for £10.

3 comments

  1. Christian Bell Jul 5 2016 at 5:53 am

    What an excellent article! Drawing is such an important form of inquiry and engagement with art. One is even tempted to argue that large parts of an art work cannot be perceived without it. I don’t know the reason for the V&A’s decision to ban drawing in their exhibitions, however, if it is visitor management, extending opening hours may be a good first step towards solving the problem.

  2. Diane Curtin Jan 1 2017 at 12:01 am

    I’m 73, moved to Pittsburgh when I entered college. I enjoy drawing at the Carnegie Museum of Art, and Natural History. The Hall of Architecture is a favorite, there is a great horse head, and male and female figures along with Roman and Greek architecture. All bathed in the natural light coming in through the skylight above. I like drawing from three dementional figures.

    I come early in the day and avoid special exhitits. They have a good permanent art collection, I bring a small folding stool, and medium drawing pad, and pencils to work in black and white or color.

    Supplies you bring are restricted, do to an unfortuninany incident with a museum guard, a knife (?) and a modern painting. It happened years ago, and I’ve tried to see if they would soften this restriction, but they stood firm.

    I’ve drawn in the galleries seveal times over the years, and have been welcomed.by guards and personal alike. There are animals birds prehistoric animals of all kinds in the Natural History Museum. If I had grandchildRen who liked to draw, I would bring them now and then.

    I have a small drawing group I teach in the CMU Osher Program. I think I’ll suggest we meet at the museum for a few weeks to draw after the holidays. Thank for the idea!

    One more observation I have made lately at the Carnegie Museum, is a large numbers of familes with small children and strollers, I see at the Museu all of the time
    .
    There is a summer camp for children at the Carnegie. The Carnegie Library, Museems, Lecture and Music Halls are all linked together in the Oakland area of Pittsburgh, right beside the University of Pittsburgh It’s a great place to draw throughou the summer.

  3. Clarke Riedy Jan 1 2017 at 10:45 pm

    The work of drawing is neither exclusively in the hand or the mind, for that matter it may well be more in the heart. It is the heart which mediates between the inevitable conflicts of ambition and frustration, gradually informing manual dexterity with the hard won lessons of visual comprehension.

    Drawing from masterworks is a bit like the elation of copying lines of great poetry, but you realize that the act of writing is quite different from that of composing. Simply writing is neither highly observational nor creative, whereas drawing from nature is both. That is how the masters arrived at both their skills and the aesthetic judgement that permits them to compose masterworks.

    Museums have many purposes, and to pit the proprietary interests of pedestrian viewers with those of the student of visual art technique is contrary to both. Many museums offer special hours for drawing study. In any case, not to be redundant, the place to learn drawing is in the life class.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *