In the news
Keeping time – the Tunisian clock monuments that tell of a bygone regime
A decade after the uprisings that led to the downfall of Zine El Abidine Ben Ali, the clocks he loved remain
The medieval Armenian monuments in Nagorno-Karabakh must be protected
The region is full of important sites that have not yet been fully recorded or studied
Most popular
- google_a
- Recent
- google_a
- Recent
Podcast
The Apollo 40 under 40 podcast: Mohamad Hafez
The Syrian-born, US-based artist talks to Gabrielle Schwarz about his sculptural dioramas of cities ravaged by war – and offers a message of hope for the future
Art news daily
The week in art news – world’s oldest animal painting found in Indonesia
Plus: Smithsonian scales back $2bn redevelopment plan | Naomi Beckwith appointed deputy director and chief curator of Guggenheim | and Champs-Élysées to be turned into ‘extraordinary garden’
The week in art news – Indian Supreme Court approves plans for new parliament complex
On Tuesday, the Supreme Court of India dismissed objections to the construction of a new parliament complex in New Delhi. The plans, announced…
Bill restituting artefacts to Benin and Senegal passes into French law
The French parliament has finalised the restitution of 26 artefacts to the Republic of Benin and one to Senegal. Speaking…
Reviews
Period pieces – the fashion for putting dates on domestic objects
From commemorative wares to ordinary utensils, inscribing dates on household objects was once common practice
Jennifer Packer’s paintings pack a punch at the Serpentine
The artist’s powerful canvases are full of detail but never shy away from the bigger picture
The Spoliation Advisory Panel and Art Restitution Claims
Tate has agreed to return Constable's 'Beaching a Boat, Brighton' (1824) on the recommendation of the Spoliation Advisory Panel
Share
Last week it was announced that the Tate would return a Constable painting to its rightful owners after investigations determined that it had been looted during the Nazi era. Claims have also been made against the Victoria and Albert Museum and the Ashmolean Museum, who have both agreed to submit Meissen porcelain pieces in their collections for investigation by the Spoliation Advisory Panel.
But what exactly is the Spoliation Advisory Panel, and how does it work? We contacted one of the panel members, Martin Levy, to find out more about the people working behind the scenes in the UK to bring restitution cases to their best conclusion:
It was an enormous privilege to have been invited, in 2000, to join the Spoliation Advisory Panel. The Panel includes distinguished historians, economists, philosophers, lawyers and museum professionals. My own involvement is probably based on a modest understanding of the historic (and present) art market.
The Panel’s role is to assess claims for spoliated paintings, drawings and works of decorative art in British public collections, which the Statute of Limitations would otherwise otherwise preclude. After an extensive examination of evidence, not infrequently mutually accepted by both owners and claimants, the panel is empowered to adjudicate on whether, on the balance of probability, an object was lost as a result of Nazi persecution. The panel’s recommendations are then presented to the Minister for Culture.
The Spoliation Advisory Panel was appointed in the wake of the Washington Conference on holocaust-era assets (1998), following which museums around the world signed up to investigate works in their collections for which the provenance during the Nazi era (1933-45) remained unclear. The work of the panel has been eased by the generally cooperative way in which cases have been presented. Although the panel has not always found in favour of claimants, we have, nonetheless, seen significant paintings, drawings and other works of art restituted to the heirs of those from whom they were appropriated.
The first chairman of the panel was the retired High Court judge Sir David Hirst (1925-2011); it is presently chaired by Sir Donnell Deeny, a judge in the High Court of Northern Ireland.
The panel’s most recent decision was to recommend that John Constable’s Beaching a Boat, Brighton (Tate Gallery) be returned to the descendants of the family who lost possession due to Nazi persecution (Report, 26 March 2014).
Share
Recommended for you
Cover Story: April Apollo
Our April cover features a photograph of Matisse. He is ensconced in cut-out design, intent on working the line
Art and Life at Kettle’s Yard
‘Art & Life’ is a touring exhibition, but Kettle’s Yard is clearly its spiritual home
Christophe Leribault, Petit Palais, Paris: April Apollo
In Apollo’s April issue we spoke to Christophe Leribault, director of the Petit Palais in Paris