The art world must do more to support experts

27 March 2017

The likely closure of Christie’s South Kensington (CSK), which was mooted by the auction house in early March while the contemporary sales were still spurting in London, has been met with widespread disappointment by collectors, art dealers, and curators – indeed by almost anyone with an interest in the fine and decorative arts, including many current and former employees of Christie’s. Writing for Apollo online – where I urge you to read her article – Susan Moore describes how ‘the move smacks of corporate short-termism as well as hubris [and Christie’s] putting all its eggs in one or two baskets – modern and contemporary art.’

The auction house has defended the proposed closure of its saleroom dedicated to mid-range art and antiques by pointing out that the market for such material has increasingly migrated online. But surely even the chief bean-counter at Christie’s recognises that it is not (yet) possible to feel the weight or texture of an object, or get any real sense of its condition from images viewed online, however high resolution. Experts still need to assess objects before they are posted on websites.

The most consistent reaction to the CSK news has been to rue the further atrophying of auction house expertise in traditional collecting fields (it is anticipated that many of the proposed 250 job losses at Christie’s relate to the closure of CSK). One former CSK staffer wrote on social media that her three years there ‘proved to be the best experience anyone in the art world could wish for [in] a remarkable and unique environment for learning, selling and developing connoisseurship’. There is a nice reminder here that financial and cultural valuation, though not the same thing, overlap in important ways in traditional fields – and that value can still be related to knowledge.

This brings us to well-trodden ground, and to the long-lamented death of connoisseurship. In a world in which cultivating the clients of the future were as important as chasing those of today, Christie’s would have revamped its South Kensington saleroom as a place in which people might have trained not just (as employees) to be experts but (as clients) to be collectors. Such an idea seems remote from the company’s current strategy.

Let them bask in their Basquiats. The broader demise of the type of knowledge gained through close looking, handling, and researching objects should be of concern not only to the art trade but also to museums and academic art historians. For how, in the future, will we continue to define the significance and quality of artworks if we lack the experts to distinguish between them? And how will we succeed in preserving heritage if all things are increasingly studied only through images? It is time to get over the tired cries of elitism. It is not elitist to know about materials and makers, and how and why they were prized in the past.

The planned closure of CSK has generated more anger than resignation, suggesting that there is life in the experts yet. Now is the moment for those who lament the passing of connoisseurship to make the strongest possible case for what is at stake, and to work together to encourage its revival. We have already seen some of the younger Old Masters dealers give their field a shot of razzamatazz. At its best, that glamour acts as a grace note to expertise, taking exceptional paintings and sculptures and making us all feel involved in them.

That is not a model that will work in all fields, but the principle of inspiring or stirring people through an unprecedented intimacy with historical objects has many applications. I urge art dealers to do all they can to work with A-level and university art-history students, welcoming groups to discuss and handle objects; university art-history departments might even offer credit for researching them. And art fairs should set up formal programmes to host junior curators for handling sessions and workshops – after all, every fair has its lulls, and what more profitable way to fill them?

I encourage readers to send in further ideas that might help to revive connoisseurial knowledge. Then let’s turn them into actions.

From the April 2017 issue of Apollo. Preview and subscribe here.

One comment

  1. Lucy Salisbury May 15 2017 at 12:25 pm

    In response to your call (Apollo Magazine April 2017) for ideas to help revive connoisseurial knowledge I wanted to let you know about ARTiculation and in particular ARTiculation Discovery Days.

    ARTiculation was established ten years ago at The New Art Centre, Salisbury, Wiltshire by The Roche Court Educational Trust. It directly engages with around 4,000 young people a year across England, Scotland, Ireland and in partnership with the British Council in Italy.

    This public speaking and art appreciation initiative gives young people a forum in which they are able to express their own responses and conclusions on art, artefacts and architecture, reached through personal observation, research and critical and contextual analysis.

    ARTiculation Discovery Days were introduced specifically for students from 14 to19 years old who would not otherwise have direct experience of art or public speaking.

    Jointly designed by Professor Abigail Harrison-Moore from the University of Leeds, and myself ARTiculation Discovery Days are offered free to schools with a higher than average pupil premium uptake.

    The first Discovery Day was held at Chatsworth, Derbyshire by kind invitation of the Duke of Devonshire and subsequently have spread to over fifty museums, galleries and collections across all ARTiculation regions including The Ashmolean, Oxford, Fitzwilliam, Cambridge, British Museum, London, The Ikon Gallery, Birmimgham, Hepworth Wakefield, Leeds, Whitworth, Manchester, Folkestone Triennial,Kent, Lismore Castle, Ireland, and the Villa Borghese, Rome.

    During the day pupils are able to observe artworks at first hand, research the works using primary sources held in the venues archives including original letters, press cuttings, invoices, diaries, poems etc. Most importantly the students are able to ask questions of the venue experts including directors, chief curators, archivists, conservators and sometimes even the artists themselves.

    I will not forget the pupils amazement when the Duke of Devonshire picking up a large and virtually priceless Delft tulip vase explained that the flowers displayed in the vase had been far more valuable than the vase itself. At the end of the day pupils give a short group presentation on their findings and personal responses to the host experts.

    Pupil’s evaluation shows that the passion, depth of knowledge and the expertise of the art professionals is the most influential part of the day along with having access to private spaces; for example the print room at Windsor Castle or the basement archives in the National Gallery. The experience is often life changing for pupils who can arrive saying they don’t like art and leave vowing to return and bring their friends and family.

    My own passion for passing on my love of art and the impetus for my career designing inclusive and accessible gallery and museum education programmes, including ARTiculation, was greatly influenced by my being the beneficiary of the Kettles Yard Student Picture Loan Scheme in the late 1970’s.

    Despite having no prior knowledge of the C20th artists (I was studying High Renaissance Art) the excitement of choosing and hanging original art works in my shabby and often damp student accommodation led me to observe and research them minutely in order to proudly introduce an original Edgar Wallis or Christopher Wood to visiting friends.

    I therefore strongly suggest that any museums who may, for example, have a few hundred Neolithic axe heads stored in their vaults should loan them to schools, like library books or the school hamster, for pupils to take home where they too will be able to take ownership and pride.

    I like to hope that through ARTiculation and ARTiculation Discovery Days the next generation of custodians, collectors, patrons and connoisseurs of our rich cultural heritage are being fostered.

    With best wishes

    Lucy Salisbury
    Founder of ARTiculation

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *